AfriForum has appealed to Land Reform and Rural Development Minister Mzwanele Nyhontso to intervene in a long-running land tenure dispute affecting farmers in Thembisile Hani Local Municipality, Mpumalanga. The organisation says the farmers have not received the long-term lease agreements or ownership rights needed to provide certainty for their agricultural operations.
A list of 75 affected farmers was attached to a letter sent to the minister. According to AfriForum, some of the farmers and their families have lived on and worked the land for decades, but remain without secure formal arrangements governing their occupation and use of the farms.
Unanswered request prompts escalation
The latest appeal follows communication from the Limamlimi Farmers’ Association to Nyhontso that, according to AfriForum, has not received a response. AfriForum and the association decided in September to work together on land tenure security, and the civil rights organisation has now asked the minister to address the farmers’ concerns directly.
Barend Uys, AfriForum’s Head of Intercultural Relations and Cooperation, said the provincial department had indicated that contracts could not be concluded with the farmers. However, AfriForum says agreements have been signed with a small number of farmers, which it argues raises questions about the consistency and transparency of the process.
| Issue | Details in the appeal |
|---|---|
| Farmers affected | 75 listed by AfriForum |
| Area | Thembisile Hani Local Municipality |
| Requested intervention | Ministerial action on land tenure security |
| Organisations involved | AfriForum and the Limamlimi Farmers’ Association |
Concerns over communal property associations
The letter also raises concerns about the establishment of Communal Property Associations (CPAs) and what AfriForum describes as unclear and questionable land allocations to those bodies. The organisation says these arrangements threaten the viability of farming operations and have already been associated with violence.
AfriForum’s submission alleges that the uncertainty is not limited to formal ownership or leases. It says access to agricultural inputs and financial assistance, including grants, development funding and loans, has in some cases been used by officials in the provincial department as a form of reward rather than being distributed through a fair and lawful system.
Those allegations create the impression, according to AfriForum, that favouritism, abuse of authority and corruption are widespread in decisions involving leases and agricultural support. The claims have not been independently established in the source material, and no response from the provincial department or the minister was provided.
Impact on farming operations
Uys argues that farming depends on decisions made over many years. Producers need to plan, invest capital and carry substantial operating costs before the results of that investment can be realised. Without confidence that farmers will be allowed to remain on and use the land, AfriForum says it becomes difficult to justify spending on productive operations or to secure financial backing.
The organisation says the lack of secure tenure has already contributed to the collapse of farming enterprises. It further alleges that families have been left destitute and that the dispute has been linked to loss of life. These are serious claims, but the source does not provide details of the affected operations, the alleged incidents or any investigations into them.
What the farmers are seeking
At the centre of the appeal is a request for certainty over who may occupy, farm and invest in the land. The farmers are seeking long-term tenure arrangements or ownership, according to the appeal, rather than informal or short-term assurances that may not support investment and succession planning.
- Formal tenure: long-term leases or ownership rights for affected farmers.
- Transparent administration: clear and lawful rules for land allocation and support.
- Access to finance: fair consideration for grants, development funding, loans and agricultural inputs.
- Ministerial intervention: a response to the farmers’ representations and oversight of the unresolved dispute.
The matter places the focus on the balance between land reform objectives and the practical need for stable farming enterprises. It also raises questions about the oversight of provincial land administration, particularly where different farmers appear to have received different treatment regarding contracts.
For now, AfriForum’s intervention is a formal appeal for the national minister to examine the situation in Thembisile Hani and provide direction. The requested response, if forthcoming, could clarify the status of the farmers’ applications, the role of CPAs in the disputed allocations and the criteria used when deciding who receives leases, agricultural inputs or financial assistance.