Case moves beyond preliminary hearing
A 44-year-old Schuylkill Haven man charged in a fatal shooting in Allentown will face the next stage of the criminal court process after a preliminary hearing Monday. Magisterial District Judge Michael D’Amore ordered all charges against Barrett Griggs held for court, according to a release from Lehigh County District Attorney Gavin P. Holihan.
Griggs is charged with felony counts of criminal homicide and possession of a prohibited firearm. His formal arraignment in Lehigh County Common Pleas Court is scheduled for Dec. 8. He remains held in the Lehigh County Jail without bail. The case has not resulted in a conviction, and the charges remain allegations to be tested in court.
What investigators say happened
Allentown police were called at approximately 8:17 p.m. Sept. 29 to the area of South Front and East Cumberland streets. Officers found a man suffering from several gunshot wounds. The victim, identified as 41-year-old Jaroe J. Perry of South Whitehall Township, was taken to an area hospital, where he was pronounced dead.
Lehigh County Coroner Dan Buglio ruled Perry’s death a homicide. According to court documents, investigators said a handgun recovered near the shooting scene contained ammunition consistent with shell casings found close to Perry’s body. Police later identified Griggs as the suspected shooter.
Evidence outlined in court papers
A juvenile witness, whose identity is being withheld, told investigators that a verbal dispute began inside a home in the 900 block of South Filmore Street. The witness said Perry later went outside, while Griggs returned indoors before coming back with a firearm and firing at him, according to the affidavit.
Investigators also reported obtaining surveillance video that they say captured the homicide. Court papers further state that officers spoke with Griggs while he was in a holding cell. The affidavit attributes the following statement to him:
“No ifs, ands, or buts about it, I did it. I just want to know if he is alive.”
The evidence described in the affidavit will be part of the broader criminal case as it proceeds in Common Pleas Court. The preliminary hearing was not a trial; its purpose was to determine whether the charges should continue forward.
Related case from the same night
Authorities also charged Abdidahir Nieves, 39, of Allentown, with criminal homicide in a separate shooting that occurred the same night. Prosecutors describe that matter as unrelated to the case against Griggs. Nieves was held for court Nov. 3, and his formal arraignment is scheduled for Dec. 10.
- Defendant: Barrett Griggs, 44, of Schuylkill Haven
- Victim: Jaroe J. Perry, 41, of South Whitehall Township
- Next hearing: Formal arraignment scheduled for Dec. 8
- Custody status: Held in Lehigh County Jail without bail
The investigation was conducted by Allentown Police Detective Joshua Faust and Lehigh County District Attorney’s Office Homicide Task Force Detective Amaury Almonte. The prosecution will be handled by the district attorney’s office, including Chief Deputy District Attorney personnel, according to the release.
For Allentown residents, the case now shifts from the initial charging phase into the county’s broader felony court system. That transition is a routine but significant step in homicide prosecutions: prosecutors must present the case through additional hearings and trial proceedings, while the defense retains the opportunity to challenge the evidence. The scheduled arraignments in this case and the separate Nieves matter will keep both fatal-shooting prosecutions before the courts in December.